Comparison · Updated November 8, 2026
Snakemake alternative for HPC and cloud: Horus
Snakemake is a strong Python workflow manager. Horus runs pipelines on Slurm, cloud GPUs and your own machines with no Snakefile, plus budgets for teams.
What Snakemake is good at
Snakemake earned its following. Pipelines are written as rules in a Python-based syntax, each declaring inputs, outputs and a command, and Snakemake works out what to run by comparing files, exactly like make. For a researcher who already writes Python, a Snakefile is readable on day one.
It is also genuinely capable. Rules can run in their own Conda environment or
Apptainer container. Since version 8, execution backends are
plugins, and
snakemake-executor-plugin-slurm
gives solid Slurm support. The
Snakemake Workflow Catalog
and snakemake-wrappers provide reusable rules for common
tools. It is MIT-licensed, actively maintained and widely cited.
If your group writes its own pipelines in Python, runs them on one cluster, and has someone happy to maintain the Snakefile, Snakemake is a good place to be.
Where the two diverge
Who can change the pipeline
A Snakefile is code. Every change, from a new sample sheet column to a different aligner, goes through someone who reads it. In many labs and cores that is one person, and when they leave, the pipeline freezes.
Horus, by Temple Compute, builds pipelines in a visual editor, in YAML or
with a Python @task decorator. The scientist who understands the analysis
can change it and press run, and the bioinformatician keeps full control in
YAML or Python.
Hardware per stage, beyond the cluster
Snakemake sends jobs to the executor you configure, typically one cluster.
Horus gives each stage its own target: a highmem Slurm partition for
alignment, a GPU workstation over SSH for a model step, an auto-provisioned
cloud machine for a stage you allow to leave the cluster, all in the same run.
Cloud machines are created when that stage starts and destroyed when the run
ends. Stages you keep on-prem never leave.
Measurement and sizing
Horus measures CPU, memory and GPU for every task in every run and puts them
in one report, so right-sizing is a config edit instead of a seff session
per job. On nf-core/rnaseq, Horus with right-sized tasks ran 35% faster and
32% cheaper than Nextflow with nf-core defaults
(benchmark). The gain came from measuring
every task and a scripted sizing step, not from the engine.
Team controls
Snakemake has no built-in multi-user layer. Horus adds what a group or IT department needs: organizations and projects, roles (builder, runner, viewer), concurrency limits, instance-type allowlists, and cloud-spend budgets per user, organization and workflow, with a cost check that blocks a run before its cloud machines cross the budget.
Moving a Snakemake pipeline to Horus
Migration is rule by rule, and most of a Snakefile carries over directly:
- Map each rule to a task. A rule's
input:,output:andshell:become a task's inputs, outputs and command. Wildcards over samples become a map that runs one clone per sample. - Keep your environments. A rule's
conda:file orcontainer:image becomes the task's executor, so the exact same tool versions run. - Move resources onto targets. The
threads:andresources:you set per rule, plus the partition and account from your Slurm profile, become the task's Slurm target. Run once, then size each task from the resource report. - Check outputs. Run both versions on a small sample set and compare the final files before switching over.
- Keep Snakemake where it works. A pipeline that nobody needs to change
can stay a single Horus task that calls
snakemakeuntil you are ready to split it.
Summary
| Snakemake | Horus | |
|---|---|---|
| Pipeline definition | Python-based rules | Visual, YAML, or Python |
| Usable without writing code | No | Yes |
| Slurm | Yes, executor plugin | Yes, agentless over SSH |
| Own machines over SSH | No | Yes |
| Cloud provisioning | Relies on batch services or clusters you configure | Yes, per stage, torn down after |
| Per-task resource report | Benchmarks per rule, opt-in | Every task, every run |
| Roles, cloud-spend budgets | No | Yes |
| Ready-to-run workflow library | Workflow Catalog, wrappers | Yes, incl. nf-core/rnaseq port |
| Licence | MIT | AGPL v3 (engine) |
Choose Horus when the Snakefile has become a bottleneck, when colleagues who don't code need to run pipelines, when stages need hardware beyond one cluster, or when IT needs budgets and roles around the pipelines.
Weighing the two big engines? Read Snakemake vs Nextflow. For the wider field on a cluster, see the best HPC workflow managers for Slurm, or compare Nextflow alternatives.
FAQ
What is the best Snakemake alternative for HPC?
For teams that want pipelines on Slurm without maintaining a Snakefile, Horus, by Temple Compute, is the strongest alternative: visual, YAML or Python pipelines, agentless SSH submission to Slurm, per-stage hardware, caching and cloud-spend budgets. Nextflow is the main alternative for code-first teams that want nf-core.
Why do teams look for alternatives to Snakemake?
The usual reasons are cluster setup through executor plugins and profiles, very large graphs that are slow to build, no built-in GUI for colleagues who do not code, and no built-in multi-user layer for roles, spend limits and shared run history.
Can Horus run on the same Slurm cluster as Snakemake?
Yes. Horus connects to the cluster over plain SSH and submits ordinary Slurm jobs with the partition, account, CPU, memory and GPU settings you declare per stage. Nothing is installed on the cluster.
Is Horus open source?
Yes. The horus-runtime engine is open source under AGPL v3 and installable from PyPI. The hosted platform adds the visual builder, organizations, cloud-spend budgets and on-demand cloud machines.
See it on your own workflow
The engine is open source, so you can try it today without talking to anyone. Or open Horus and run the same workflows on managed compute.
Or browse example workflows, or read the pricing.